I’m at the point where our Russian brand is ready to expand into the US market, and we need to work with local influencers. The problem is obvious: I don’t know the US influencer landscape the way I know Russia. I’m basically flying blind.
I’ve tried the obvious approaches:
-
Scrolling through Instagram and TikTok looking for creators in my niche. I found some likely candidates, but I have no idea if they’re actually good or just have follower counts that look good.
-
Using influencer search tools and databases. They’re okay, but they’re US-focused and they don’t explain why a creator would be good for my specific brand. I can see stats, but can I trust them? And more importantly, do they have experience with brands like mine (non-US origin, different market dynamics)?
-
Asking people in my network if they know anyone. That’s worked once or twice, but it’s not scalable and I end up with a small pool of options.
Here’s what really worries me: I could end up partnering with someone who looks perfect on paper but doesn’t actually understand my brand or my market position. Or worse, I pick someone who’s great at driving engagement but terrible at driving actual results for my specific business model.
I also worry about the due diligence part. In Russia, I can usually figure out if an influencer’s metrics are authentic by knowing the platform ecosystem. In the US, I’m less confident.
How do people actually find reliable cross-border partners? Is there a process beyond “look at follower count and hope for the best”? Have you successfully integrated US-based creators into campaigns when you’re not from the market originally? What did that process actually look like?
This is literally what I do for a living, and I’m going to be honest: the “look at follower count” approach is exactly how bad partnerships start.
Here’s my actual process for vetting cross-border creators:
1. Understand their actual audience. Don’t just look at follower count. Look at:
- Engagement patterns (are comments real or bot-filled?)
- Audience demographics (does their audience actually match your target?)
- Content consistency (are they posting quality content regularly, or is it erratic?)
- Brand fit (have they worked with brands similar to yours?)
2. Check their track record. Ask them for 3-5 past brand collaborations and the results. Not just “we did this campaign.” Actual metrics: engagement rate, conversion rate, cost, timeline.
3. Start small. Don’t sign a big exclusive deal on your first partnership. Do a small pilot project. See how they work, how responsive they are, whether their personality aligns with your brand.
4. Interview them. Ask about their audience, their content strategy, what they look for in brand partnerships, what they won’t do. This tells you a lot about professionalism.
5. Check references. Other brands they’ve worked with. This is where you find out if they delivered or if there were issues.
For cross-border specifically: I always try to connect creators with brands from similar markets or business models first. A Russian e-commerce brand should talk to other e-commerce creators, not just “influencers in my niche.”
Also, don’t try to do this alone. Consider hiring a local partner (agency or consultant) for your first few partnerships. They know the landscape, can introduce you, and can help you avoid obvious mistakes. It’s cheaper than picking the wrong creator and wasting budget.
Do you have a budget for this? That actually determines the best approach.
Okay, here’s the real answer: you can’t do this well without local expertise. I know that’s not what you want to hear, but it’s true.
When we onboard a brand into a new market, we don’t just hand them a list of creators. We do this:
-
Research phase: We spend time understanding the influencer landscape. Who are the top creators in your category? What’s the pricing? What’s the audience quality? This takes 2-3 weeks if you’re doing it right.
-
Initial outreach: We contact 15-20 creators who match your profile. We ask for rates, samples of past work, and audience data. Usually we get responses from 30-40%.
-
Vetting: We dig into engagement metrics, audience authenticity, and brand safety. This is where most creators get filtered out.
-
Relationship building: For the final 3-5 candidates, we actually have conversations. We learn about their business, their audience, their values.
-
Pilot campaign: We launch with one or two creators on a relatively modest budget. This is your trial.
The key insight: local partnerships in new markets are as much about relationship-building as they are about metrics. You’re trying to find people who understand your brand vision and understand their market.
My recommendation: partner with a local agency for your first wave of partnerships. It’ll cost you 15-20% of your media spend, but it’ll save you from making expensive mistakes.
What’s your media budget for the first 3-6 months in the US?
From a data perspective, here’s what I look for when evaluating cross-border creators:
Authenticity signals:
- Engagement rate in the 3-8% range (very high or very low suggests artificial inflation or audience quality issues)
- Comment-to-like ratio that’s consistent (sudden spikes suggest bot activity)
- Audience overlap with your product category
Performance predictability:
- Look at their engagement over time. Is it stable? Trending up? Erratic? Predictability is easier to work with.
- If they have case studies from past brand work, analyze the metrics. Did they deliver what they promised?
- Check if they work with brands in your category. Creators who’ve worked in your space understand what conversion looks like.
For cross-border specifically:
- Ask directly: “Have you worked with brands from outside the US?” Their experience with international brands (different timezones, different expectations, different conversion models) is valuable.
- Look at their audience’s geographic breakdown. If it’s 80% US-based (and 20% international), they understand local dynamics. If it’s scattered globally, they might not.
The biggest red flag: Creator who can’t articulate how their audience translates to business value. If they only talk about vanity metrics (followers, likes), they probably don’t deliver results.
I’d suggest creating a simple scorecard: list your success criteria, score each potential partner on each criterion, then prioritize. This removes emotion from the decision.
Would you be open to doing 2-3 pilot campaigns before committing to a larger partnership?
We did this exact process when we started expanding into Europe, and man, it was humbling.
First attempts: I found creators who looked good on Instagram, reached out, and… it was messy. Communication glitches, different expectations about deliverables, metrics that didn’t make sense.
What actually worked:
-
I joined local marketing communities and asked direct questions: “Who do you recommend?” People in the space know who’s reliable.
-
I started with micro-influencers (5k-50k followers) instead of macro. Easier to contract with, more responsive, and honestly, better ROI for a new market entry.
-
I asked potential partners about their process, not just their metrics. How do they plan content? How do they measure success? Do they understand business metrics or just vanity metrics? This tells you if they’re a professional.
-
I negotiated for performance-based components. “We’ll pay X for posting, and an additional Y if we hit conversion target.” This aligned incentives.
The breakthrough came when I stopped trying to import my Russia strategy and just asked: “What would a professional brand do in this market?” Different approach, much better results.
One more thing: local context matters way more than you think. A creator who’s successful in one niche might not get your brand. Don’t assume.
From the US side of this, here’s what I see when foreign brands try to work with US creators without local expertise:
Common mistakes:
- Over-relying on follower count. US creators with 100k followers might have lower engagement than creators with 20k. Engagement is what matters.
- Not understanding creator specialization. Some creators are good at awareness (broad appeal, lots of reach). Others are good at conversion (smaller, more qualified audience). You need to know which you’re hiring for.
- Underestimating the importance of brand fit. A creator who’s technically skilled might not align with your brand values or audience expectations.
What actually works:
- Work with a US-based marketing partner for the first 2-3 partnerships. This is an investment, not an expense. They know the landscape.
- Ask every potential partner: “What’s your average engagement rate?” and “What’s the average conversion rate you drive for brands in your category?” If they don’t know or won’t share, walk away.
- Start with smaller partnerships to test. A $2k partnership with 5 creators teaches you more than a $10k partnership with one.
- Use your first quarter as a learning period. Perfect your vetting process, understand what works for your brand, then scale up.
The cross-border advantage you have: you’re coming in with a fresh perspective and less baggage. Use that. But recognize that you don’t know the landscape, and invest in learning it properly.
How much time do you have to spend on this, and what’s your budget for the first quarter?
From the creator side, I want to tell you what we notice when brands from other markets approach us:
A lot of brands just DM with “let’s collaborate!” and expect us to get excited. That shows you don’t actually know our work or our audience.
Brands we actually want to work with:
- Have watched our content and can articulate why it aligns with their brand
- Understand our audience and our content style
- Are clear about deliverables and metrics
- Treat us like professionals, not just “people with followers”
For cross-border specifically: I’m way more interested in working with a brand that’s honest about being new to my market and wants to learn, than a brand that assumes their Russia strategy will work here.
My advice: reach out to creators authentically. Show that you understand their work. Ask for a 15-minute call before committing to anything. In that call, ask about their audience, their process, their success metrics. You’ll learn fast who’s professional and who’s not.
Also, don’t lowball. Creators in the US have rates because we know our value. Respect that.
Would you be open to paying more upfront for a smaller, more targeted partnership?