I’ve lost count of how many campaigns I’ve seen tank because the creator’s audience looked good on paper but turned out to be 60% bot followers or completely misaligned with the brand’s actual customer. And the thing is—you can’t always tell just by looking at their engagement rate or follower count.
A few months back, I was vetting creators for a premium skincare campaign, and one creator kept coming up in recommendations because they had 800k followers and decent engagement on their posts. But when we actually looked at the audience breakdown, their followers were mostly 18-24 year old males in Southeast Asia—completely incompatible with the brand’s target demographic of women 25-45 in North America and Europe.
That’s when I realized I was doing the work backwards. I was checking if the creator “looked good” instead of checking if their audience was actually the people the brand needed to reach.
Now I approach it differently:
First, I pull real audience data. Not just follower count—actual geography, age, interests. Most platforms have this built in now, and if a creator won’t share it, that’s honestly a red flag.
Second, I look at comment patterns. Are the same accounts always engaging? Do comments feel real or copy-pasted? I’ll actually spend 20 minutes reading through recent post comments to see if the engagement feels organic.
Third, I check historical patterns. Did this creator just suddenly gain 200k followers in a month? Did their engagement drop recently? Those things tell a story about what’s going on underneath.
Fourth, I ask the creator directly. “How do your followers break down by geography? What’s your audience’s actual purchase intent?” If they know their own audience, you’re in good shape. If they don’t, that’s a problem.
The bigger question I’m sitting with now is: how much of the vetting process can actually be systematized? And when you’re working across markets (say, Russian-rooted creators targeting US audiences, or vice versa), how do you validate that the cultural fit actually works, not just the demographic fit?
What’s your system for pre-qualifying creators before you even have that first call?