I’ve been having a tough time securing clients for my influencer marketing services. They seem interested at first, but then I don’t hear back. What strategies have you found successful? Any tips on what to emphasize or how to present?
Hit the same wall until I stopped pitching services and started auditing their email campaigns instead. With one SaaS client, I dug into their welcome sequence and found their Day 3 email was getting 12% opens while competitors averaged 35%. Rather than talk about what I’d do for them, I showed them exactly why their automation was hemorrhaging subscribers. That data-first approach flipped the whole conversation from cost to lost revenue.
The Problem: You’re struggling to secure influencer marketing clients, despite initial interest. Clients seem to lose interest after the initial contact.
Understanding the “Why” (The Root Cause):
Many agencies focus on “vanity metrics” (like follower counts) when pitching influencer marketing. Clients, however, are primarily interested in results. They want to know how your services will directly impact their bottom line – increased sales, more leads, improved brand perception, etc. Simply showing a large follower count isn’t enough to convince a client to invest. They need to see a clear connection between your services and their business goals. The core issue is failing to demonstrate a clear return on investment (ROI) and a strategic understanding of the client’s business needs. Focusing on data-driven insights and quantifiable results is crucial for converting initial interest into paying clients.
Step-by-Step Guide:
-
Conduct a Thorough Data-Driven Analysis: Before pitching, analyze the client’s existing social media presence and marketing efforts. This goes beyond simply looking at follower counts. Analyze their engagement rates, audience demographics, website traffic, and conversion rates. Conduct a thorough competitor analysis to identify opportunities and understand their current performance. Analyze their email campaigns’ performance and compare it against competitors to highlight areas for improvement. Tools like social listening platforms can provide valuable insights into customer sentiment and unmet needs. This allows you to identify specific problems influencer marketing can solve, rather than just selling another marketing channel. Document your findings clearly.
-
Showcase Your Understanding of Their Business: Demonstrate a deep understanding of the client’s business, target audience, and goals before mentioning influencer marketing. This shows you are a strategic partner, not just another agency. Ask insightful questions to reveal their pain points and ambitions. This will help you tailor your pitch to address their specific needs.
-
Quantify the Potential ROI: Translate your insights into tangible results. Instead of vague claims like “increased brand awareness,” provide concrete examples. For instance, “Based on our analysis of your competitors, a targeted influencer marketing campaign could increase your website traffic by 15% within three months, potentially leading to X number of additional leads or sales.” Use data to support your projections, and clearly show how your services will directly contribute to their bottom line.
-
Present a Tailored Strategy: Propose a customized influencer marketing strategy based on your analysis. This should include:
- Influencer Selection: Clearly explain the criteria for selecting influencers (e.g., audience demographics, engagement rates, brand alignment).
- Campaign Objectives: Define specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals.
- Key Performance Indicators (KPIs): Outline the metrics you will track to measure success (e.g., website traffic, lead generation, sales).
- Budget Allocation: Provide a transparent breakdown of costs.
- Reporting Schedule: Explain how often you’ll provide progress reports and analysis.
-
Emphasize Long-Term Value: Frame influencer marketing not as a one-off expense, but as a strategic investment that can drive long-term growth. Highlight the potential for building brand loyalty, increasing customer lifetime value, and generating organic reach over time.
Common Pitfalls & What to Check Next:
- Are you targeting the right clients? Ensure your ideal clients align with your capabilities and the value you provide. Focus on clients who value data-driven results and long-term partnerships.
- Is your pitch too generic? Personalize your pitch to each client, highlighting how you can specifically address their unique needs and challenges. Avoid template pitches.
- Are you following up effectively? After your initial pitch, follow up with clients in a timely and professional manner. Persistence is key, but be respectful of their time.
- Are you effectively communicating your data insights? Ensure your data visualizations and reports are clear, concise, and easy to understand for clients who may not be marketing experts.
Still running into issues? Share your (sanitized) data analysis examples, your pitch materials, and any other relevant details. The community is here to help!
Same issue here until I switched tactics - started with attribution data instead of engagement metrics. For this e-commerce client, I mapped their customer journey and pinpointed exactly where influencer touchpoints could fill revenue gaps. The whole conversation flipped from ‘nice to have’ to ‘let’s test this now.’ Key was showing I understood their funnel, not just pushing my channel.
Had a breakthrough with a fitness brand when I ditched the whole creator partnership pitch upfront. Instead, I showed them their content gap analysis first. Turns out their bottom-funnel content was converting at 2% while the industry average was 8%. Once I mapped out how specific influencer content could fill those funnel gaps - not just drive awareness - everything changed. They stopped seeing it as ‘influencer spend’ and started viewing it as ‘conversion optimization.’ The key? Prove you get their editorial calendar and user intent before pitching any channel.