I’m at the point with our DTC brand where I know we need to scale UGC in the US market, but I’m hitting a wall: how do you find creators here who aren’t just chasing trends, but who actually understand what we’re about?
Our brand has this specific story—we came from Russia, we had a real problem we were solving, and it shaped everything about how we operate now. When creators in the US work with us, we need them to understand that origin story genuinely, not just parrot marketing language.
Right now I’m basically cold-outreaching creators on TikTok and Instagram, sending them DMs with our standard partnership pitch. Response rate is… okay. But when they do respond, I can tell pretty quickly whether they actually get the brand or if they just see a paycheck.
I’ve heard some people talk about using the community here to source creators, or leveraging partnerships that already exist. But I’m not quite sure how that actually works in practice.
A few specific things I’m struggling with:
-
How do you even identify which creators are genuinely aligned with your values? It’s easy to look at follower count and engagement. Harder to know if they’ll represent your brand authentically.
-
Is there a smarter way to find creators than cold outreach? I feel like I’m wasting time. There’s got to be a network or list or something.
-
When you do find someone good, how do you structure a longer-term partnership instead of just one-off deals? That seems to be where the real trust-building happens, but I don’t know how to even propose that.
I know a lot of you are working with creators across markets, or you’re creators yourselves who work with international brands. What’s actually working for you? What should I be doing differently?
Okay, this is literally what I do all day, so let me give you the real answer: cold outreach scales, but it’s not the right approach for what you’re describing.
If you want creators who genuinely understand your brand story, you need warm intros. Not connections on LinkedIn, but actual referrals from people who’ve already vouched for you.
Here’s my actual workflow:
-
Map your network first: Who do you already know in the creator/marketing space in the US? Even loosely. Start there.
-
Ask for referrals: Tell these people exactly what you’re looking for—not just “creators with 50K followers” but “creators who value authenticity” or “creators in the eco/wellness space who think critically.”
-
Use community platforms: This community forum, actually, is a goldmine for this. Post about what you’re looking for, and people will send you recommendations. I’ve made some of my best creator partnerships through forum recommendations.
-
Tier your approach: Have a short list of creators who are “perfect fit” (they’ll get your story naturally). Invest relationship time there. Have a longer list of creators who are “good fit” (they can execute but might need more guidance). Contact them differently.
For structuring longer partnerships: don’t propose “let’s do 3 UGC pieces together.” Instead, propose becoming a “brand partner” where they get first access to new products, invitation to your strategy discussions, maybe a small retainer or monthly budget. Position it as “we want your thoughts on our direction, not just your content.”
The creators who say yes to that? Those are your people.
I’d honestly say 60% of successful creator partnerships start with a recommendation, not a cold DM. Change your sourcing strategy first.
I want to add something data-driven to Светлана’s advice (which is solid): when you’re vetting creators for brand alignment, look at their audience composition and content patterns, not just their bio.
Specifically:
-
Audience demographic data: What are their followers actually interested in? You can use tools like Social Blade or just analyze their comment threads. Look for values alignment, not just demographic alignment.
-
Content consistency analysis: Look at their last 20-30 posts. Do they actually stand behind the products they recommend, or do they promote everything that pays? Creators with selectivity = more authentic recommendations.
-
Engagement quality over quantity: 30K followers with 2% engagement (mostly substantive comments) beats 100K with 0.5% (mostly bots/spam). Quality engagement means their audience actually trusts them.
-
Cross-platform presence: Do they show up consistently across platforms with a coherent brand? Or are they different people on TikTok vs Instagram? The former is more trustworthy long-term.
Then, once you’ve identified 5-10 creators who score well on these metrics, do a small test: send them a product without any partnership ask. Just a gift. See what they do. Do they mention it unprompted? Do they tag you? Do they integrate it naturally? That’s your real signal.
Yes, it takes longer than mass cold outreach. But your conversion efficiency (and brand trust) will be 3-5x better.
What does your current creator acquisition cost look like right now? That would help me give you more specific benchmarks.
Real talk: we tried the cold outreach thing when we entered the European market. It was inefficient and honestly depressing. So we shifted.
What actually worked for us was finding people in the ecosystem who already understood our market positioning, and asking them to introduce us to creators they trusted. Sometimes it was marketing agency friends. Sometimes it was other founders. But these people understood our story, so they could recommend the right creators.
For you: it sounds like you need people in the US market who genuinely get Russian-origin brands or at least understand global expansion. Those people exist in consulting, in agencies, in creator networks. Find them. Buy them coffee (or schedule a call). Explain your story. Ask for creator recommendations.
It’ll feel slower upfront, but the quality of creators you’ll connect with is incomparable.
One more thing: when you do find creators, be honest about your brand’s story. The ones who connect with it authentically will. The ones who don’t will self-select out. That’s actually good. You don’t want creators who don’t get you.
How long have you been trying the cold outreach so far? And what’s your current response rate?
From an agency perspective, I’d say: outsource this problem to someone who already has the network.
I know that sounds self-serving, but here’s the reality: finding and vetting the right creators is a specialized skill. It’s not a sales process; it’s a partnership development process. If you’re doing it yourself and it’s taking cycles away from your core business, you’re optimizing for the wrong thing.
That said, if you’re going DIY, here’s what actually works:
-
Use creator marketplaces smartly: Klear, Influee, AspireIQ—these let you filter not just by follower count, but by audience values, content themes, engagement quality. Spend time setting up the right filters before you reach out.
-
Build a “creator brief” document: Instead of a generic pitch, create a 1-page brief explaining your brand story, origin, values, and what you’re looking for. Send this before proposing a partnership. If they’re interested after reading it, then you have a real conversation.
-
Start with smaller creators: Micro-influencers (10K-100K followers) are often more selective about partnerships and more authentic. They’re also less booked up, so they’ll engage with you.
-
Create a structured onboarding: Once you find someone, have a clear process for how you work together—communication cadence, content approval, timeline, payment terms. This professionalism attracts serious creators.
Longer partnerships come naturally if you nail the first collaboration. Don’t overthink it. Do one project excellently, and propose the next one based on results.
What’s your timeline for finding creators? Are you looking to launch campaigns in 30 days or more like 90?
Okay, from a creator’s perspective: the brands I want to work with long-term are the ones who treat me like a partner, not a vendor.
When you reach out to creators, here’s what actually stands out to me:
-
You’ve actually researched my content: Not “Hi, you have followers in X niche.” But “I watched your video about [specific thing] and loved how you approached [topic], which aligns with our values because [your story].” That shows you’re serious.
-
You’re transparent about what you want: Don’t dance around it. Tell me what you’re looking for, what budget you have, what creative freedom I have. Honesty is attractive.
-
You’re interested in collaborating, not directing: The best partnerships I’ve had are with brands where they say “here’s our story, here’s what we need, how would you approach this?” Not “here’s the script, please read it.”
For longer partnerships: most creators will say yes to that if the first collaboration goes well and you’re clear about what it looks like. Like, “if this works, I’d love to do monthly partnerships where we collaborate on content strategy together.” That’s appealing because it’s not just transaction-based.
One thing: sometimes creators turn down partnerships not because they don’t like the brand, but because they’re worried about authenticity. If your values actually align, tell them that upfront. Remove the doubt.
As for “finding” creators—honestly, some of my best brand partnerships started because someone in my network recommended me, or because I’ve been following a brand and reached out first. Make your brand easy to recommend. Make your story easy to understand. The right creators will find you.
What’s your vibe as a brand? Like, what would someone say you’re about?
Let me give you a strategic framework for this, because there’s a system here that most people miss.
Creator selection shouldn’t be random. It should be strategic and data-informed:
Step 1: Define your creator persona matrix
What you actually need is a 2x2 matrix: (1) audience alignment, (2) brand value alignment. Plot creators on this. You want top-right: high on both.
Step 2: Tier your creators
- Tier 1 (5-10 creators): Essential—they represent your values perfectly. Invest relationship time. Consider retainer partnerships.
- Tier 2 (20-30 creators): Good fit. Transactional partnerships. One-off campaigns.
- Tier 3 (sourcing pipeline): Monitor. Develop relationships over time.
Step 3: Source strategically
- Use referral networks (like this community) for Tier 1
- Use creator platforms + data filtering for Tier 2
- Use algorithms + organic discovery for Tier 3
Step 4: Test before scaling
Give each Tier 1 creator a small project first. Measure not just performance, but how well they understood your brief, how much creative direction they needed, how authentic the output felt. This data informs whether you scale to longer partnerships.
Step 5: Measure fit, not just performance
Don’t only look at conversion rates. Look at:
- How well did they embody your brand values in the content?
- What was the conversation quality in comments?
- Did their audience seem genuinely interested, or just passively scrolling?
The Russian brand story angle is actually your advantage here, not a burden. Creating content around an authentic origin story is more interesting than generic brand messaging. Creators who get that will actually want to work with you.
How much time do you want to invest in creator sourcing vs. creator management once you find them? That’ll determine whether you do this DIY or outsource.